You can choose a different firmness level for each side of the bed, making the Naturepedic mattress ideal for couples.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
Naturepedic Mattress Review: We Tested this Customizable Non-Toxic Bed
Updated on Sep. 24, 2024
If I had $1 for every time I thought about how my husband and I needed a new mattress, I’d buy an island. Our Beautyrest mattress had seen better days, and its once firm edges were dipped and didn’t offer the same support it did years ago. I wasn’t sure what firmness level I—or my husband, for that matter—would prefer, so I felt comfortable testing out the customizable Naturepedic mattress.
This non-toxic mattress allows you to swap out the inside layers. So, if you find that you chose the wrong firmness level or, after years of slumbers, it starts to give, you can swap out a piece of the mattress instead of getting rid of the whole thing. I don’t know about you, but that instantly gave me peace of mind when making a decision as personal as a mattress.
On This Page
What is the Naturepedic Mattress?
This Naturepedic mattress, labeled EOS Classic Organic Mattress (Latex-Free), is certified non-toxic and organic by Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), meaning it’s free of harmful and allergenic substances. This model also comes in a non-latex-free version (I’m just allergic to latex, so I went with the other one). You can shop it in sizes twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king—all with a 12-inch profile.
CAITLYN FITZPATRICK/FAMILY HANDYMAN
We Tried It
Naturepedic EOS Classic Organic Mattress
Each side of this mattress can have its own firmness level, allowing you to choose between plush, medium, cushion-firm and firm.
Naturepedic Mattress Features
What makes this Naturepedic mattress so special is that you’re not married to whatever firmness level you choose, which tends to be a major concern when selecting the best mattress. This non-toxic bed has inserts, meaning it doesn’t come all in one piece, including the customizable 3-inch glueless micro-coil layer and the customizable 8-inch glueless encased coil support layer. So while, yes, there’s quite a bit of assembly with this model, if you’ve found you’ve ordered the wrong firmness level, you can simply swap out the internal components to get the right feel for your sleep. Or, if after many years of snoozing, you find that it’s more worn in than you’d like, you can get a new insert rather than an entirely new bed. It’s a convenient feature that makes the buying decision easier.
How We Tested It
My Naturepedic mattress was quick to deliver but took some time to set up. Still, the comfortable sleep was worth it. Here’s how I tested this mattress.
Delivery
My order was placed on Monday, the mattress shipped that Wednesday, and it arrived on my front porch that Friday. I was delighted, as I was so over my old mattress and practically foaming at the mouth for my Naturepedic to arrive. It showed up in four separate boxes, so I was thankful that the delivery man slid them into my living room.
The main shell and the inserts are wrapped separately, so it does take time to remove them from the box and unwrap them from the plastic. I made the error of doing all of this in my living room. What I should’ve done was unbox the components, bring them upstairs to my bedroom and unwrap them there. Instead, I did all of that downstairs and had to drag each piece up the stairs. It wasn’t ideal, but that’s on me.
Assembly
I’m going to be honest: The idea of putting together a mattress wasn’t exactly exciting to me. But now I see that, long story short; I’d rather have to assemble it and have the option of switching out its contents rather than have a mattress in a box that turns out to be totally wrong for me and have to deal with shipping the whole thing back.
Before you even get started, I can’t stress enough how helpful this video from Naturepedic was. It goes through each step and gives helpful tips so you know exactly what to do.
Now, I’m not the most patient of people, which means that I couldn’t wait for my husband to be available to set up this mattress. Plus, I was so over our old one that I couldn’t bear spending one more night with less-than-optimal sleep. So, once our old mattress was out of the way, I first brought the Naturepedic shell casing upstairs and laid it on top of our metal bed frame. Then, it was a matter of placing each layer inside of that casing. My husband and I both chose cushion-firm firmness, so our sides were exactly the same.
Assembling the Naturepedic mattress wasn’t difficult, per se. The challenge is that the pieces fit very snugly inside the casing—as you’d want them to so there aren’t any gaps (and there aren’t!)—so you have to be strategic with ensuring each layer is in the right place and tightly so. After all the layers were in on each side, it was time to zip up the entire thing. This part did cause me to break a sweat. In hindsight, it definitely would’ve been easier had I waited for my husband because one of us could’ve held the top and the side close together while the other one zipped. It took a lot of effort for one person to do this.
But I did it all by myself—not that I’d recommend it, but it can be done.
Sleeping
It had been over 10 years since I had picked out a new mattress, so I wasn’t sure what firmness my previous one was and what I’d like. Plus, my old mattress was worn in, so it didn’t feel the same as it had on day one. Among the four firmness level options—plush, medium, cushion-firm and firm—my husband and I each opted for cushion-firm. When it arrived, I was nervous because it felt quite firm. At one point, I thought maybe the wrong ones were sent. But everything was correct, and I was ready to put this Naturepedic mattress to the test.
On that first night, I noticed right away how different it felt from my old mattress. This one was firmer, as expected, but I also noticed how it felt getting in and out of bed. The edges were strong and supported my weight as I moved. It didn’t have that sunken-in feeling as only a very old model does. I appreciated that from the start. If you had asked me before this if I like a firm mattress, I would’ve said absolutely not. My parents have a firm memory foam mattress, and I’ve napped in it before while dog-sitting. I’ve never liked it. The difference between theirs and mine is that mine is made of coils, and it isn’t firm-firm. So, while it’s not stiff as a board, it’s still very supportive.
It only took me a few nights to decide that I love this Naturepedic mattress. It turns out that cushion-firm is the perfect firmness for me. In fact, I regularly get knots in my left shoulder, which results in my left arm going numb and leaving me in a lot of pain. Since sleeping on the Naturepedic mattress, I’ve noticed those knots are less regular and less severe. I take it that my body likes it, and it’s more supported than it was before. And as an every-position sleeper, I’m happy whether I’m on my side, back or stomach.
My husband also got the cushion firm on his side of the bed, but he hasn’t fallen in love with it like I have. He finds it too firm and would prefer something softer. Since it’s only been a little over a month, I want him to give his body more time to adjust. But if, after that, it still hasn’t broken in to his liking, we know we have the option of swapping out the firmness level. Imagine if we had to send back the entire mattress. Not only would I be disappointed because I love my side of the bed, but it would be a bit of a headache.
Pros
- Customizable firmness on each side
- Swappable inserts
- Four firmness options
- Certified non-toxic and organic by GOTS
- Latex-free
- Available in sizes twin to California king
- Fast delivery
- Free shipping and returns
- 100-night trial
- 25-year warranty
Cons
- Requires assembly
- Pricey (if not on sale)
Why You Should Trust Us
I’ve been an editor and writer since 2014 and in the editorial commerce world, where I test products, write about products and edit shopping stories, since 2017. I’ve covered everything from beauty products to strollers to, yes, bedding, including cooling sheets and a cooling comforter. As the senior shopping editor at Reader’s Digest, a sister site of Family Handyman under Trusted Media Brands, I understand the important information shoppers want to know, and I strive to provide an in-depth perspective.
I’m particularly qualified to review this Naturepedic mattress because it’s latex-free, and I’m allergic to latex. My allergy has only gotten worse as I’ve gotten older, so testing a latex-free mattress was super important to me, even though a non-latex-free one would be covered with a mattress topper and sheets anyway. You can never be too careful.
FAQ
Where are Naturepedic mattresses made?
All Naturepedic mattresses, foundations, toppers, pillows, and other products are made in the U.S. using domestic and imported fabric and components. Most of the brand’s products are made in its GOTS-certified organic factory in Ohio.
Does Naturepedic have fiberglass?
Naturepedic eliminates all fiberglass, flame retardants and chemical flame barriers from its products. Still, the brand passes all government flammability standards.
Who owns Naturepedic?
Naturepedic was founded by Barry A. Cik, a board-certified environmental engineer who saw a need for organic crib mattresses over twenty years ago.
What Other Reviewers Had to Say
From over 20 reviews, this Naturepedic mattress has earned an average of 4.7 out of five stars.
“I tried several different beds and found them all to be too hot, and even latex being too warm for me. In my search for a new bed, I became aware of the harmful chemicals in most mattresses. So, I decided that I needed a non-latex, organic mattress,” writes Grace, a verified buyer. “I decided to try the Naturepedic EOS with microcoils. I started out with cushion-firm and found it too soft. Swapping for firmer coils was easy and now I have the perfect bed. It sleeps cool and I can rest easy knowing that I’m not breathing in toxic chemicals.”
“I’m sensitive to latex, even the clean/pure Dunlop latex seems to bother my breathing. [It] makes my breathing more shallow, which is an immune response. Many organic beds are made with latex. I still wanted an organic bed being a person spends so much of their life in bed, but I needed to find something latex-free. Enter Naturepedic latex-free,” writes Steve, a five-star reviewer. “I am beyond pleased with the product! It is super high quality. I do woodworking as a hobby and am very detail oriented. Also, my job is very detail oriented at work. Trust me when I say it is high quality!”
Product Comparison: Naturepedic vs. Newton Mattresses
Naturepedic started out focusing on organic crib mattresses and has since expanded to beds for kids and adults, too. Newton is another popular mattress brand for babies, kids and even pets. When deciding between Naturepedic vs. Newton mattresses for your little one, there are some differences to consider.
Naturepedic offers three crib mattresses: classic, breathable and ultra-breathable. They start at $269, and all of them are waterproof, lightweight, or feature coils. The differences come in with the type of cover, if any, and the number of coils. Most importantly, all of Naturepedic’s crib mattresses are 100% certified organic and free from harmful chemicals. Plus, the brand offers free shipping, a 100-night trial, free returns and a limited lifetime warranty.
Newton also has three crib mattresses (not including its mini crib option): original, waterproof and essential. Starting at $199, the three mattresses are Greenguard Gold Certified. The original and waterproof are 5.5 inches thick and designed for ages 0 to 4, while the essential is four inches thick and made for ages 0 to 3. Each one has a zippered, washable cover, but the essential is a single layer; the original is a quilted double layer, and the waterproof liner is a quilted double layer waterproof liner. Just like with Naturepedic, you also get free shipping, a 100-night trial, free returns and a limited lifetime warranty.
When it’s time to choose one of the brands, keep these core factors in mind. For one, Newton’s crib mattresses are all two-stage models to accommodate your child through the toddler years. But with Naturepedic, you have the option of single-stage or two-stage. On the flip side, all of Naturepedic’s crib mattresses are waterproof, but only one of Newton’s models is waterproof—an important consideration since babies tend to get messy. It all comes down to what features are most valuable to you.
Final Verdict
Naturally, you’re going to consider the pros and cons more strongly when making a more expensive purchase. The Naturepedic mattress takes away some of the common cons associated with shopping for a mattress. Being able to customize each side of the bed—and swap out the firmness insert if you realize you made the wrong choice—should instantly put your mind at ease, as it did mine. When you couple that with its non-toxic, organic stamp of approval from GOTS, it’s pretty hard not to feel safe with this model.
Where to Buy the Naturepedic Mattress
The Naturepedic EOS Classic Organic Mattress (Latex-Free) is available on the brand’s website starting at $2,199. You can also add on a foundation starting at $399, but it’s not necessary to enjoy the bed. Naturepedic has other organic mattresses starting at $1,399 and are available at other retailers, including Pottery Barn, Crate & Barrel and Amazon.
CAITLYN FITZPATRICK/FAMILY HANDYMAN
We Tried It
Naturepedic EOS Classic Organic Mattress
This mattress is certified non-toxic and organic, so you can sleep soundly knowing it’s free of harmful and allergenic substances.
